Appeals and
Review in GST
Tax laws (or any laws, for that matter) impose obligations.
Such obligations are broadly of two kinds: tax-related and procedure-related.
The taxpayer’s compliance with these obligations is verified by the tax officer
(by various instruments such as scrutiny, audit, anti-evasion,
etc.), as a result of which sometimes there are situations of actual or
perceived non-compliance. If the difference in views persists, it
results into a dispute, which is then required to be resolved.
Tax law recognizes
that on any given set of facts and laws, there can be different opinions or
viewpoints. Hence, it is likely that the taxpayer may not agree with the
“adjudication order” so passed by the tax officer. It is equally possible that
the Department may itself not be in agreement with the adjudication order in
some cases. It is for this reason that the statute provides further channels of
appeal, to both sides.
However, since the
right to appeal is a statutory right, the statute also places reasonable
fetters on the exercise of that right. The time limits prescribed by the
statute for filing of appeals and the requirement of pre-deposit of a certain
sum before the appeal can be heard by the competent authority are examples of
such fetters on the statutory right.
GST being implemented
in our country is a dual GST i.e. to say every supply attracting the levy will
be leviable to both central tax and state tax. So
does this mean that if a taxpayer is aggrieved by any such transaction, he will
have to approach both the authorities for exercising his right of appeal? The
answer is a plain NO. The Act makes provisions for cross empowerment between
CGST and SGST/ UTGST officers so as to ensure that if a proper officer of one
Act (say CGST) passes an order with respect to a transaction, he will also act
as the proper officer of SGST for the same transaction and issue the order with
respect to the CGST as well as the SGST/UTGST component of the same
transaction. The Act also provides that where a proper officer under one Act (say
CGST) has passed an order, any appeal/review/revision/rectification against the
said order will lie only with the proper officers of that Act only (CGST Act) So
also if any order is passed by the proper officer of SGST, any appeal/review/revision/rectification
will lie with the proper officer of SGST only.
Appellate Mechanism
A person who is aggrieved by a decision or order
passed against him by an adjudicating authority, can file an appeal to the
Appellate Authority (AA, for short). It is important to note that it is only
the aggrieved person who can file the appeal. Also, the
appeal must be against a decision or order passed under the Act. It
is to be noted that no appeals whatsoever can be filed against the following
orders:-
·
An order of the
Commissioner or other authority empowered to direct transfer of proceedings
from one officer to another officer;
·
an order pertaining to
the seizure or retention of books of account, register and other documents; or
·
an order sanctioning
prosecution under the Act; or
·
an order passed under section
80 (payment of tax in instalments).
The time limit for the
party to file an appeal is 3 months from the date of communication of the
impugned order. But the AA may condone a delay of up to one month, if he is
satisfied that there was sufficient cause for such delay.
The AA has to follow
the principles of natural justice – such as hearing the appellant, allowing
reasonable adjournments (not more than 3), permitting additional grounds (if
found reasonable), etc. The AA can also make such further inquiry as may be
necessary.
On conclusion of the
appeal process, the AA will pass his order (Order-in-Appeal) which may confirm,
modify or annul the decision or order appealed against but shall not refer
the case back to the authority that passed the said decision or order.
The AA can also increase the “rigour” of the order appealed against by enhancing any fee or
penalty or fine in lieu of confiscation or confiscating goods of greater value
or reducing the amount of refund or input tax credit, but this can only be done
after the AA has given to the appellant a reasonable opportunity of showing
cause against the proposed order. Further, if the AA is of the opinion that any
tax has not been paid or short-paid or erroneously refunded, or where input tax
credit has been wrongly availed or utilized, no order requiring the appellant
to pay such tax or input tax credit shall be passed unless the appellant is
given notice to show cause against the proposed order and the order is passed
within the time limit specified under section 73 or Section 74 of the CGST Act,
2017.
The Order-in-appeal
has to be a “speaking order” i.e. it should state the points for determination,
the decision thereon and the reasons for the decision. The law provides an
advisory time limit of 1 year from date of filing of appeal for the AA to
decide the appeal.
Appeals before Tribunal
The Tribunal is
the second level of appeal, where appeals can be filed against the
orders-in-appeal passed by the AA or order in revision passed by revisional authority, by any person
aggrieved by such an order-in-appeal/Order in revision.
The law envisages
constitution of a two tier Tribunal i.e. National Bench/Regional Benches and
the State Bench/ Area Benches. Jurisdiction of the two constituents of the GST
Tribunal is also defined. If place of supply is one of the issues in
dispute, then the National Bench/ Regional benches of the Tribunal will have
jurisdiction to hear the appeal. If the dispute relates to issues other than
the place of supply, then the State/Area Benches will have the jurisdiction to
hear the appeal. An appeal from the decision of the National Bench will lie
directly to the Supreme Court and an appeal from the decision of the State
Bench will lie to the jurisdictional High Court on substantial questions of
law.
Appeal to the Tribunal
by the aggrieved person is to be filed within 3 months from the communication
of the order under appeal. Further, Tribunal has the power to condone delay (of
up to 3 months in case of appeals or 45 days in case of cross objections,
beyond the mandatory period) on being satisfied that there is sufficient cause
for the delay. The Tribunal has the discretion not to admit any appeal
involving an amount of Rs. Fifty Thousand or less.
The law also provides
for filing of cross-objections by the respondent against such
part of the order against which the respondent may initially not have chosen to
file an appeal. It is provided that on receipt of notice that an appeal has
been filed (by the appellant), the party against whom the appeal has been
preferred (i.e. the respondent) may, notwithstanding that he may not have
appealed against such order or any part thereof, file within 45 days a
memorandum of cross-objections against any part of the order appealed against
and such memorandum shall be disposed of by the Appellate Tribunal as
if it were an appeal presented within the time specified for the
initial appeal. Condonation
of delay (on sufficient cause) applies here also, but only to the extent of
further 45 days from the date of expiry of the period for filing cross
objections. The form, fees, etc. for the appeals to Tribunal shall be as
prescribed by Rules.
The Tribunal after
hearing both sides may pass such orders thereon as it thinks fit, confirming,
modifying or annulling the decision or order appealed against or may refer the
case back to the AA or to the revisional authority,
or to the original adjudicating authority, with such directions as it may think
fit, for a fresh adjudication or decision, as the case may be, after taking
additional evidence, if necessary. For reasons of natural justice (reasonable
opportunity) it is also provided that the Tribunal may, if sufficient cause is
shown, grant up to 3 adjournments
to either side.
Concept of pre-deposit
As mentioned earlier,
the right to appeal is a statutory right which operates within the limitations
placed on it by the law. One such limitation flows from the principle that an
appellant must first deposit the adjudged dues before his further appeal can be
heard. However, often an appellant may succeed in his appeal, and hence it
would (in retrospect) be unfair to saddle him with this financial burden. To
balance these factors, tax laws mandate some “pre-deposit” so as to discourage
frivolous appeals and also safeguard the bonafide interests of both the
taxpayers and the revenue.
The CGST Act, 2017 require an appellant before AA to
pre-deposit full amount of tax, interest, fine, fee and penalty,
as is admitted by him, arising from the impugned order and a sum equal to 10%
of the remaining amount of tax in dispute arising
from the impugned order.
In so far as appeals
to the Tribunal is concerned, no appeal can be filed before the Tribunal unless
the appellant has deposited in full, such part of the amount of tax, interest,
fine, fee and penalty arising from the impugned order, as is admitted by him,
and a sum equal to 20% of the remaining amount of tax in dispute, in addition
to the amount deposited before the AA, arising from the said
order, in relation to which appeal has been filed.
If the pre-deposit
made by the appellant before the AA or Tribunal is required to be refunded
consequent to any order of the AA or of the Tribunal, as the case may be,
interest at the rate specified in Section
56 shall be payable from the date of payment of the amount (and not from
the date of order of AA or of the Tribunal) till the date of refund of such
amount.
Appeals by the Department (CGST/SGST) before the
AA/Tribunal
At times, the Department itself
is not in agreement with the decision or order passed by the (initial)
adjudicating authority or the appellate authority. The GST Law provides that in
such cases, the Department can file what is commonly known as a “review
application/appeal”.
The GST Law gives
powers to the Commissioner to review any order passed by his subordinates
acting either as an adjudicating
authority, or the appellate authority or revisional
authority. If the Commissioner is of the view that any order passed by such
authorities are not legal and proper, he can direct any officer subordinate to
him to apply to the competent authority. For example, if the order of
adjudicating authority is reviewed, he can order his subordinate to file an
appeal before the appellate authority. If the order of the appellate authority
or the revisional authority is reviewed, he can
direct his subordinate to file an appeal before the Tribunal. The grounds for
appeal will be mentioned in his order. The review of the order and the
consequent filing of appeal by the subordinate has to be done within a period
of six months from the date of communication of the order. The resultant review
application is required to be dealt with by the AA or the Tribunal as if it
were an appeal made against the decision or order of the adjudicating authority
and the statutory provisions relating to appeals shall, so far as may be, apply
to such application.
Revision by Commissioner (CGST/SGST)
The GST Act also provides for the mechanism of revision, by the Revisional Authority, of the orders passed by his
subordinate officers. If the Revisional Authority on
examination of the case records is of the view that the decision or order
passed by any officer subordinate to him is erroneous in so
far as it is prejudicial to the interest of the revenue, and
is illegal or improper or has not taken into account material facts, he
may, if necessary, stay the operation of such decision or order for
such period as he deems fit and after giving the person concerned an
opportunity of being heard and
after making such further inquiry as may be necessary, pass such order, as he
thinks just and proper, including enhancing or modifying or annulling the said
decision or order.
The above power is
subject to the condition that non-appealable orders and decision cannot be
revised. Further the power of revision cannot be exercised if: -
·
the order has been
subject to an appeal before AA or Tribunal or High Court or Supreme Court; or
·
the period of six
months (from the date of communication of order) has not yet expired or more
than three years have expired after the passing of the decision or order sought
to be revised; or
·
the order has already
been taken for revision at an earlier stage; or
·
the order sought to be
revised is a revisional order in the first place:
If the said decision
or order involves an issue on which the Appellate Tribunal or the High Court
has given its decision in some other proceedings and an appeal to the High
Court or the Supreme Court against such decision of the Appellate Tribunal or
the High Court is pending, the period spent between the date of the decision of
the Appellate Tribunal and the date of the decision of the High Court or the
date of the decision of
the High Court and the date of the decision of the Supreme Court shall be
excluded in computing the period of limitation of 3 years where proceedings for
revision have been initiated by way of issue of a notice under section 108 of
the CGST Act, 2017.
However, the Revisional Authority may pass an order on any point which
has not been raised and decided in an appeal before AA/Tribunal/HC/SC, before
the expiry of a period of one year from the date of the order in such appeal or
before the expiry of a period of three years from the date of initial order,
whichever is later.
Concept of authorised
representative
Any person who is
entitled or required to appear before a GST Officer or the AA or the Tribunal
in connection with any proceedings under the Act, may appear through an authorised representative (except when
he is required under the Act to appear personally for examination
on oath or affirmation).
For this purpose, “authorised representative” has been defined in the Act
itself. Broadly, it includes a relative, a regular employee, an advocate, a
chartered accountant, a cost accountant, a company secretary, or any person
with prescribed qualifications. It is also provided that indirect tax gazetted officers can appear as authorised
representative after one year from retirement.
The GST law also
provides for some disqualifications for an authorised
representative such as dismissal from government service, conviction under
some specified Acts, insolvency, misconduct, etc. Such orders of
disqualification are, however, required to be passed after following the
principles of natural justice.
Appeal to the High Court
The law provides that either side (department or party) if aggrieved by
any order passed by the State Bench or Area Bench of the Tribunal
may file an appeal to the High Court and the High Court may admit such
appeal if it is satisfied that the case involves a substantial question
of law. It is to be noted that on facts, the tribunal is the final
authority.
Appeals to the
High Court are to be filed within 180 days, but the HC has the power
to condone delay on being satisfied of sufficient cause for the same.
On being satisfied
that a substantial question of law is involved, the High Court shall formulate
that question, and the appeal shall be heard only on the question so
formulated. However, the High Court has the power to hear the appeal on any
other substantial question of law if it is satisfied that the case involves
such question. The High Court shall decide the questions of law so formulated
and deliver such judgment thereon containing the grounds on which such decision
is founded and may award such cost as it deems fit. The High Court may
determine any issue which has not been determined by the Tribunal or has been
wrongly determined by the Tribunal, by reason of a decision on such questions
of law.
Appeal to the Supreme Court
The law provides for
appeals to the Supreme Court from any judgment or order passed by the High
Court, in any case which, on its own motion or on an oral application made by
or on behalf of the party aggrieved, immediately after passing of the judgment
or order, the High Court certifies to be a fit one for appeal to the Supreme
Court.
A (direct) appeal
shall also lie to the Supreme Court from any orders passed by the
National/Regional Bench of the Tribunal. It may be noted that the
National/Regional Bench of the Tribunal has jurisdiction to entertain appeal if
the dispute or one of the issues in dispute involves place of supply.
0 comments: